Hearing Summary: A Carpenter Denied Every Benefit Until Trial

Why a Trial Firm

Hearing Summary: A Carpenter Denied Every Benefit Until Trial

Zero paid in medical. Zero paid in wage benefits. A written demand ignored.

This is an anonymized summary of a real Missouri workers’ compensation case our firm took to a final hearing in December 2024. Names are removed to protect the client’s privacy, and the parties are referred to as Employee, Employer, and Insurer, the same convention the Division uses.

Updated October 2026: on September 29, 2026, the Missouri Court of Appeals reversed the denial of medical bills in this case. See What Happened on Appeal below.

The dollar figures below are the amounts our firm presented and asked the Division to award at the hearing. Every case is different; results depend on the facts.

30+ Years Missouri workers’ comp only$100M+ Recovered for clientsDirect Access Talk directly with James

100% Free Consultation

Ask about a denied claim

A few details are enough to start. Attorney James M. Hoffmann reviews every inquiry.


The Case

What Happened

Employee was a full-time carpenter building cabinets and retail displays. The displays ranged from 60 to 500 pounds, and carts arrived all day carrying 100 pounds of materials each for him to lift and assemble. In the fall of 2017, the low back soreness that came with the job turned into severe pain with numbness running down his right leg.

He reported a repetitive-use injury to his low back in October 2017. The Employer sent him to an occupational clinic; when severe pain met long delays, he went to urgent care on his own and returned to work with a light duty slip. For months afterward he asked for treatment and kept the Employer informed of the care he was getting on his own. In December 2017 he hand-delivered a written demand for treatment. The Insurer sent authorizations, took his recorded statement, and authorized nothing.

In February 2018, the Employer ended his light duty and sent him home. No wage benefits followed. Employee underwent two back surgeries on his own that year. When he recovered and returned to work in November 2018, the Employer fired him.

Missouri carpenter with severe low back pain from repetitive lifting at work
Every benefit denied, with no medical opinion behind the denial.

Denied Everything

An Answer With No Medical Opinion Behind It

When the claim was filed, the Employer and Insurer filed an Answer denying every benefit. Seven years later at the hearing, they produced no medical opinion supporting that denial, no explanation for the ignored demands, and no evidence of any non-work cause for Employee’s back condition.

The stipulations told the story in two lines. Medical paid: $0.00. Temporary disability paid: $0.00.

The Hearing

Proving a Repetitive Trauma Case at Trial

Repetitive trauma cases rise or fall on medical causation: whether the job duties were the prevailing factor in causing the condition. Employee’s surgeon related the herniated discs and both surgeries to the work, the firm’s retained medical experts connected the job’s lifting demands to the condition, and the opinions the Insurer hired for trial were challenged piece by piece on cross-examination.

The firm also moved for sanctions under Section 287.560 RSMo for the denial of care and benefits without any supporting medical opinion. The Employer answered with a sanctions motion of its own, arguing Employee should have accepted a settlement offer. That is what trying a case against a total denial looks like.

The Ask

What the Firm Asked the Division to Award

At the close of the hearing, our firm asked the Division to hold the Employer and Insurer responsible for:

  • $248,116.98 in denied medical bills, including both surgeries
  • $28,376.01 in denied temporary total disability, covering 39 weeks
  • Permanent partial disability of 35% of the low back
  • Future medical care for life for Employee’s low back
  • Sanctions of 25% of all amounts awarded plus $23,383.41 in the firm’s costs to prosecute the denied claim

In total, the firm asked the Division to award $453,608.64. More of the firm’s tried and settled cases are on our case results page.

On Appeal

What Happened on Appeal

The hearing judge awarded disability but refused to order the Employer to pay the denied medical bills. The judge reasoned that three weeks was not enough time for the Employer to evaluate the written demand for surgery, and that a lien agreement with the surgeon showed the Employee never intended to accept authorized care. The Labor and Industrial Relations Commission affirmed that award in full.

We appealed to the Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District. On September 29, 2026, the court reversed the denial of medical bills and sent the case back to the Commission with instructions to calculate the Employer’s liability for all treatment after the February 14, 2018 demand for surgery and award that sum. Both surgeries, the microdiscectomy and the fusion, fall after that date. The disability award (temporary total disability for nine months and 30 percent permanent partial disability of the body as a whole) was not challenged and stands.

Three points from the opinion matter for any injured Missouri worker whose employer goes quiet after a request for treatment:

  1. There is no evaluation window. Section 287.140 gives an employer two choices when a worker demands treatment: authorize it and keep control of the care, or refuse or ignore it and pay for whatever treatment is later found reasonable and necessary. The court held the Commission misapplied the law by giving the Employer time to “evaluate the claim.” Nothing in the statute provides one. We explain the rule in plain terms in My Employer Ignored My Demand for Surgery. Who Pays?
  2. Silence is refusal. The Employer never answered the February 14, 21, or 28 demands and never sent the Employee to a doctor of its choosing. The court said the Employer could have reasserted control simply by doing that. It did not, so it owes the bills.
  3. A doctor’s lien is not a rejection of authorized care. The Commission inferred that signing a lien with the surgeon meant the Employee would have turned down company-authorized treatment. The court called that inference speculative and unsupported, because nothing in the record showed the Employer ever offered treatment to be turned down.

The court did not award the sanctions and costs we requested under Section 287.560. It agreed the Employer acted unreasonably in failing to provide treatment, but found the Employer had some basis to contest causation because its medical examiner had offered an opinion that the back condition was mostly genetic. The Commission’s refusal to assess costs was left in place.

The medical bills at issue total about $248,000. The Commission will calculate the final award on remand. Every case is different; results depend on the facts.

This case ran from a written demand in February 2018 to an appellate opinion in September 2026. It took a hearing, a Commission review, and an appeal to get the medical bills paid. The insurer’s position at every stage was that the worker should have waited. Trying the case, and then appealing it, is what changed the answer.

A Trial Firm

The Record a Total Denial Runs Into

In 2025 alone, our firm spent over $700,000 on expert witnesses. Cases like this one are why. When an Insurer pays nothing and explains nothing, the record has to prove everything.

Our firm handled roughly 1 in 4 of recent workers’ compensation trials at the St. Louis Division of Workers’ Compensation, out of hundreds of attorneys representing Missouri workers. Insurers know which firms will actually try a case, and it changes how they negotiate.

A total denial is not the end of a claim. It is the beginning of the record a trial firm builds.

Common Questions

Questions About Denied Claims and Trials

Is repetitive trauma covered by Missouri workers’ comp?

Yes. Repetitive trauma is treated as an occupational disease under Chapter 287. The question is whether the job duties were the prevailing factor in causing the condition, and that is proven with medical opinions.

What if my employer ignores my requests for treatment?

Put the demand in writing and keep a copy, the way Employee did here. Under Section 287.140 the employer then has two options: authorize the treatment and choose the doctor, or refuse or ignore the demand and pay for the reasonable and necessary treatment you obtain on your own. In this case the Court of Appeals confirmed in September 2026 that the employer does not get a waiting period to think it over. If the claim is denied outright, there is a process for that.

Can I be fired after a work injury in Missouri?

Missouri law prohibits firing a worker in retaliation for exercising workers’ compensation rights. What happened here, a firing the same month Employee returned from his second surgery, was part of the record presented at the hearing.

Does every case end with numbers like these?

No. These figures are what our firm requested on the facts of this one case, and they are not a prediction for any other. Every case is different; results depend on the facts.

Attorney James M. Hoffmann in his St. Louis office
Attorney James M. Hoffmann · St. Louis, Missouri

About Attorney Hoffmann

Talk directly with Attorney James M. Hoffmann

For more than 30 years, James M. Hoffmann has represented injured Missouri workers, and only injured Missouri workers.

When you call, you talk with the attorney handling your case, not a call center and not a junior associate. Questions about insurance surveillance are exactly the kind to ask before you settle, not after.

Denied everything? That is not the end of the claim.

An Answer that denies every benefit without a medical opinion behind it is a case that can be tried. Free consultation. No fee unless we recover compensation.

Call (314) 361-4300Free Consultation